Katana vs Nodachi: Duel of the Japanese Blades in History and Combat. While the centerline of the spine runs straight and true, grinding the proper distal tapper into this somewhat irregular shape seems to have been a challenge and you can see waviness along the edge of the spine that I have not seen on any of the LK Chens other sabers. Indeed, he was kind enough to provide me with a translation of Suns account of its creation in the autumn of the year 2000. The entire mounting of the chng-dao is strikingly similar to Japanese swords (see also pictures of the kata forms at the end of the article). The arch of a Katana blade allowed the user to draw the sword quickly, and it was well-suited for combat. The method of polishing is also different. Although the Katana is one of the long Japanese swords, the Nodachi is significantly longer. In contrast, the Katana has a much stronger curve. The reason for this is thought to be that the conditions for making a practical large-sized sword were established due to the nationwide spread of strong and sharp swords of the Ssh school. So on a strictly functional level, the Chinese didnt necessarily produce lesser swords than the Japanese. A recent mini-documentary on the miaodao, produced and globally distributed by Chinese state television, shows a museum of display of singe handed Han dynasty calvary dao when arguing for the purely domestic origins of the miaodao. He is a high-ranking officer in Shogun's military army. I ordered the R2 original pork chop rice noodles. In picture 2 we see at least one pirate who is carrying a longer than usual sword. If you find yourself looking for a working miaodao, one would be hard pressed to find an example that is more conscious of both its 16thand 20thcentury roots. That is incorrect, based on historical fact.. What is critical to note about this account is that Guo Ruixiang was not attempting to replicate his fathers weapon. If you set a set a typical Qing dynasty Zhanmadao and a modern Miaodoa next to each other even a novice swordsman with notice several key differences. In response to some of the comments below, my two cents on quality, as someone with hands-on experience with antique Chinese swords: As far as quality goes, I think the correct answer is it depends. The Miao Dao is known as a Chinese double-handed saber that appeared during the Republican era. In An Ancient Tradition and Modern Training. and our woku) were raiding the coastlines of China and Korea for almost three centuries from the Kamakura period onwards. The Kage-ry style is also used to draw from the belt, using blades of approximately 2.8 shaku. It is made to be perfect for training in Chinese martial arts. It is a weapon that can be used both as a spear and a sword and is often compared to the Japanese Katana. None of this would come as a surprise to someone as steeped in the evolution of Chinese swords as LK Chen, and I have traded many pleasant emails with his American agent, KK Cheung, discussing the twists and turns of the miaodaos modern creation. The Piandao is a slicing saber mainly because it might be shorter and the curve goes further away from the center line. That is why it is safe to say that the Miao Daos roots are from very early on. [1], The dachi was used as a weapon, but because of its magnificent appearance, it was often used as an offering to kami, a Shinto shrine. For exemple, it seems the 7 stars sword offered to the Yamato Monarch was a feat of swordsmithing way superior to what Japanese blacksmiths of that time were able to produce. covina police scanner live. Odachi were usually more cumbersome, but they had much more strength and power per blow than a katana. In Qi Jiguang's war against the Japanese pirates, the battle with the Miao Dao was won. The blade on the Nodache (especially the open comb plate) is feel much more secure, providing a different experience (not better). Overlong swords were known and used in China since at least since the Han Dynasty (, 206 BC 220 AD) as we find names like zhnm-dao in later records on that time. Until the middle of the Kamakura period, high-ranking samurai mainly fought on horseback with yumi (bows), but as group battles by foot soldiers increased from the late Kamakura period, the importance of weapons possessed by those who did not have horses and did not have sufficient training in bows increased. This sword plays a critical role in China, especially after 1920. When thinking about these trends our mind immediately turns to the dadao, but even the jian and spear benefited from the eras enthusiasm. My one complaint about the scabbard would be that the fittings seemed to be a bit too larger and did not always fight tightly against the wood. However, an unearthed sword from the 5th century was found from a mound in Tochigi. While this move is also used in other schools, for example, Yagy Shinkage-ry, Shin mus Hayashizaki-ry and Iaid, only Enshin-ry seems to have used it to improve the drawing speed of an dachi, the other schools having used it with classical katana. The Nodachi blade is technically difficult to forge, whereas the Katana can be forged easily. Melville, N. (2019, April 5). That is why most of the Chinese Miao Dao swords you will find on the market will go for $300 and more! The broth was extremely flavorful and I enjoyed the various toppings in the soup. World War Ii Military Equipment of. In my view this is when the miaodao was really born. Indeed, he didnt seem to see any future for the older design. 152 centimetres (60in)), and fought well against the troop of Oda Nobunaga in the Battle of Anegawa. The other method was simply to carry the sheathed dachi by hand. As battlefield weapons, dachi were too long for samurai to carry on their waists like normal swords. Great article! Emperor is a character in Shadow Fight 3. This hand-forged Miao Dao sword is made of 1095 high-carbon steel and is ready for battle. That only happens in martial arts movies. To qualify as an dachi, the sword in question would have a blade length of around 3 shaku (90.9 centimetres (35.8 in)). The long and narrow Jian, which looks a lot like the Miao Dao, first appeared in China during the Western Han dynasty. The . The Miao Dao is a saber with a very slight and soft curvature. The military worked on a very low budget at the time, with decline of arms manufacture as a result. The Chinese equivalent of this type of sword in terms of weight and length is the miao dao, and the Western battlefield equivalent (though less similar) is the longsword or claymore. In an effort to reimagine earlier Ming and Ching tradition, a martial artist and military trainer named Liu Yuchan introduced miaodao troops into the armies of the warlord (and future president of the Republic) Cao Kun. The first 18-volume edition from 1560 does not contain the mokuroku. Aside from the Tachi, the Nodachi was also usually compared to the Katana. As dachi became useless, it was often replaced with a tachi and katana. The large, rounded guard not only protects the hand but also acts as a pivot point for informed techniques when it is close to the leading hand. Feel free to post memes, comments, theories, or just discussion prompts about the new and upcoming faction! The blade is flexible but not excessively so, and the pipe back profile makes the sword feel stiff in cuts and exercises. These are the best recommended Miao Dao swords weve come across on the internet. Many katana cultists on YouTube, and more katana bashing, but it seems both groups avoid this wonderful blog, sadly. Nowadays, it is still revered for its historical significance and excellent craftsmanship. [13] Its length is 465 centimetres (183in) with an overall weight of 75 kilograms (165lb). However, it was too long for the Samurai warrior to carry on their waist like regular swords. While most production swords have relatively inexpensive brass fittings, LK Chens features sleek stainless-steel furniture. Blackfencer has a dedicated synthetic miao dao if you're in Europe. Some sword enthusiasts will argue that the Katana is the strongest sword in the world, while others will argue that the Katana has already been beaten by the Miao Dao, making the Chinese sword the strongest. When comparing a katana vs. a greatsword, they differ in length by about 10 inches. Other practitioners have latched onto the name zhanmadao (horse cutting knife) and attempted to connect this relatively late innovation to the much more ancient Han dynasty fencing tradition. And the rich symbolic associations that they gather suggests something about how the process of invented tradition actually comes together. The name also means Sprout Sabre, which refers to the likeliness of a newly sprouted plant. $249.00 Add to cart Compare. Still, the urge to dissociate the dandao/changdao/zhanmadao from its obvious Japanese roots seems to have been a driving force in the modern creation of the miaodao as both an artifact and a social system. With the use of kikuchi-yari and the changes in warfare during the Nanbokuch period, the dachi entered the stage of the Japanese battlefield whereas fighting with this kind of sword should become soon the strong point of the Kage-ry. This battle-ready Miao Dao has an overall length of 55 3/4 / 1.4 meters and weighs around 3 lb 6.2 oz / 1.5 kg. Modern blades also tend to be both shorter and lighter than their ancestors. When comparing which among the Katana and Nodachi is better, it all depends on the wielders skills and abilities. and our By this point commercial swordmaking had already been reestablished in Longquan which was exporting huge number of low cost copies of Japanese swords to the global market. Well, not very long :P But it was certainly a lot of fun! According to those who used them, the difference is in the feeling. It is a sword that continued to evolve from the very early days of China and has grown to be the sword it is today. The diamond shape cross section of the tip was to be changed to a flat tip as the era of cold battle weapons is over. It feels like a straight blade while also having the benefit of attacking from an almost unnoticeable curvature. 2. 1. To paraphrase Karl Marx, while many masters seek to create new systems, approaches or styles, they are not free to do so just as they wish. Amazing Value - Fully Functional Hand Forged 65MN Spring Steel Blade - Massive Sword nearly 5' long yet far from flimsy and extremely popular with our customers. Rosewood or some other high quality wood was to be used for the hilt. Even if theres no exact size for the Nodachi, its usually referred to as a great sword or field sword. Down on Earth, these weapons were commonly used by cavalry because their greater length allowed for effective attacks by samurai on horseback. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. The Miao Dao sword, sometimes known as the long saber or the Grain Leaf saber, is a Chinese sword that is a treasured part of the Chinese cultural legacy. Yet with the proper application of distal taper (9 mm at the base of the spine, 6.5 mm one third of the way down the blade and 2.5 mm at the tip), that has not proved to be an issue. [10], Even so, sengoku-daimyo in the Sengoku period dared to equip their own troops with dachi in order to show off their strength and bravery. Sharpe, M. (n.d.). Same lenght, longsword is faster, more versatile and durable. When used by foot soldiers, they carried it on their back, and samurai would have an assistant or fellow soldier draw the sword off when needed for battle. #2. In use, the Miao Dao is safer and more lethal than the Japanese sword. dachi are difficult to produce because their length makes traditional heat treatment more complicated: The longer a blade is, the more difficult (and expensive) it is to heat the whole blade to a homogeneous temperature, both for annealing and to reach the hardening temperature. 4. Privacy Policy. While this claim is often made in miaodao circles it is not a subject that we see on any of the existing class lists from the period. The Niuweidao of the Late Qing Dynasty This was a kind of Chinese Dao that appeared during the late Qing Dynasty. Exploring this process of social creation can be a challenge. The weapons shown are the Hangaku Naginata which is being used like a Guan Dao going up. Emperor is a Three Arrows, along with Galen and Bolo. Learn how your comment data is processed. The initial results were less than stasifactory, yielding long and floppy blades. Since the odachi and nodachi were, in fact, the same weapon, its more useful to compare this weapon type to a katana. [3] A special attribute is that this blade was forged from one piece, similarly to the conventional Japanese katana;[3] it was not forged from multiple pieces or sections. Still, some historians will say that it is a 20th-century creation. Indeed, the 1920s-1930s was an important era in the history of Chinese fencing. Most historical discussions of this weapon begin with events late in the Ming Dynasty. This type of sword appears in many myths as the sword of the Gods. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Sep 11, 2018 at 11:33am AndiTheBarvarian said: Only if he has the longsword! By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. I used it sometimes. Miao Dao translates to sprout saber which refers to its likeness between a freshly sprouted plant and a weapon. The overall length of the Miao sword is around 3.9 to 4.5 feet / 1.2 to 1.4 meters. Its design was influenced by the Japanese tachi and later, the Katana. The blade length of the Miao Dao can be from 2.6 to 3.2 feet / 80 cm to 1 m long. Still, if we wish to understand the social functions that the Chinese martial arts have filled it is vitally important to know something about the periodic bursts of creative energy that are seen in these systems, as well as the more familiar patterns of traditional transmission. The Miao Dao is recognizable by its blade, which makes it seem like a long sword. The Miaodao and Invention in Chinese Martial Arts. However, they have larger blades than Samurai Katana swords. Others assume that Qi Jguang bribed several pirates to bring him as much information on Japanese warfare as possible to be used by him against the wak. Despite frequent assertions to the contrary, I can find no evidence that he formally taught the miaodao there. It is generally used in fighting techniques that require a lot of chopping and slashing. The word tachi itself is derived as the stem or noun form of verb tatsu (, "to cut off"). [9] However, infantry units gradually came to be equipped with yari (spears) in addition to naginata, and because dachi was disadvantageous for mountain battles and surprise attacks, and only a few powerful men could use it effectively, this trend ended for a short time. Avoid a razor-sharp Miao Dao, as you might injure yourself. , Including. It is greatly used in China because it is incredibly light, making attacks fully flexible and extremely quick. Yet the rise in popularity of the japanese Katana came about because of the progressing nature of close-range battles. The traditional handle of the Miao Dao was generally made with wrapped handles. My review sword came quite sharp along most of the length of the blade, but the tip itself was a bit dull and might have to be touched-up before cutting. This sword was a certain type of anti-cavalry blade utilized for battle. In fact, historical documents show that Japanese warriors used the two terms interchangeably. For more information, please see our The Nodachi is a Japanese long sword held by foot soldiers or carried on their backs. $169.00 European Swords. Given that China is once again undergoing such a moment it should not be a surprise to see the miaodao being popularized both by individual teachers and state-backed media campaigns. Last Edit: Sep 12, 2018 at 9:07pm by howler. This is a recording of a match at a Sword Arts meeting in April 2016. Long sabers of this type were popular at the end of the Ming dynasty, made famous by General Qi Jiguang. The modern maiodao, however, has an entirely different cross-section. The advantages of a katana vs. a greatsword meant that a fighter could carry on longer in battle, move faster, and recover more quickly even if it took many more strikes to finish off an opponent. Huntington, M., & Huntington, M. (1987, February 22). It takes training for one to master the techniques of the two swords. Complicating things was the fact that Guo had already decided on a number of key design features that were unlike the swords being produced in the area at the time. When calling a sword odachi, you are usually referring to the size of the weapon. While you might need time to recover from a missed blow, using an odachi effectively meant a warrior could break through a katanas parry with ease. When examining the flats of the blade under a light it is clear that there is a certain amount of waviness here, but I think that it is in-line with what you would expect from a handmade sword at this price point. But around 1999 Guo Ruixiang (then 80) began to visit local backsmiths in the Beijing and Heibi areas seeking a prototype miaodao. These types of swords were very difficult to manufacture in ancient times and were, therefore, relatively rare. The name of this miaodao should beChung Wah (Chinese)miaodao, the soul of our people. It has been around for more than 2,000 years. The Katana was able to further facilitate this by allowing the user to wear it thrust through an Obi. This makes it a perfect length for a sword that can fight in both close quarters and on open battlefields. The dachi here () is simply the voiced compounding version of the term tachi (, great sword), the older style of sword that predates the katana. Because of their size, dachi are usually hung from the ceiling or placed in a stationary position to be polished, unlike normal swords which are moved over polishing stones. I did an article on Chinese long sabers as they appear in Qing dynasty regulations of the mid 18th century: It was sometimes called the Miao Dao - a similar but more recent blade - that appears similar to that of the Japanese Nodachi. After the repeat forging and tempering comes the quenching. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Material: wood, metal, ivory, fish skin, silk, Nagasa (cutting edge): 226.7 centimetres (89.3in), Blade thickness (maximum): 2.34 centimetres (0.92in), Mei (blade signature, ): Bishu Osafune Norimitsu (), Sugata (blade shape): Shinogi-zukuri, maru-mune, bo-hi with maru-dome, This page was last edited on 30 March 2023, at 05:37. But the most obvious difference will be size. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. The Bubi-shi in turn was reintroduced to Japan and republished, for example by Matsushita Kenrin (, 1637-1704) in Genroku one (, 1688) in his work Ish-Nihon-den (). During the Ming dynasty, Japanese pirates constantly troubled the people who lived near the coast. (LogOut/ I guess that would rule out the Masamune altogether. New comments cannot be posted. Nodachi and odachi swords may not be different weapons, but they do have different meanings. A historian inside and out, David is a 26 year old graduate in the field with many certificates. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. He got a fuck long MiaoDao @@ very similar to a Nodachi in Kenjutsu. The Silver Swallows blade is truly awesome in every sense of the word. When debating whether to say odachi vs. nodachi, referring to a samurai sword as nodachi specifies the application of the sword and how its used on the battlefield. A dao sword is a single edged sword of Chinese origin that first surfaced during China's Bronze Age. Afterall, there needs to be something that memorializes the burst of energy and creativity that shaped so much of Chinese martial practice in the 1920s and again following the Cultural Revolution. It is also said that the dachi were used to cut in half the long poles with which the people from the mainland tried to keep away the Japanese pirate boats. To get an idea of the fighting techniques with the dachi, we have to make a detour via China of the late 16th century as hardly anything is known on this topic from the time this sword stlye emerged, i.e. The zhnm-dao and chng-dao were namely used to attack horses and ward off and cut in half enemy yari. However, the blades cross section does seem to have been a challenge to grind. The odachi was a brute force weapon, while the katana rewarded speed, flexibility, and timing. Realy enjoyed reading this as i knew none of the information. Anyone who would like to test this theory for themselves can pick up one of LK Chens recreations of a long Han dao which, aside from having only a single cutting edge, has no other similarities to any Chinese sword of the Ming, Qing or more modern periods. In the past, there were two primary methods of carrying these weapons. Below some kata depictions from the Tant-hsen. Please read these articles: Zhanmadao: greatmingmilitary.blogspot.com/2015/04/zhan-ma-dao.html Changdao/Dandao/Miaodao: greatmingmilitary.blogspot.com/2015/04/chang-dao.html Mentioned_Videos 2 yr. ago A sword cannot be qualified as a Nodachi if it does not measure around this. - Colonel's . Their profiles should be based on the traditional miaodao but in consideration of modern humans size, should be made a bit shorter and lighter. . The length of a nodachi was typically around three shaku (or 35.8 inches), although there is no exact definition of the size to be classified as such. A trend in the Muromachi period had the Samurai carry the Nodachi with a follower to help draw the weapon. The blade is made first from steel which is folded repeatedly over 20 times until it gets to the perfect, slightly curved state. The Miao Dao has the traits of a broadsword and a spear. Picture 2: Japanese pirates attacking a mansion. [3] It was forged by the Japanese master bladesmith Norimitsu Osafune in the former Bish province in August 1446. Nodachi literally translates to "Field Sword," while Odachi means "Large / Great Sword." For example, yamazumi Shrine, which is said to be a treasure house of Japanese swords and armor, is dedicated to the national treasure dachi, which was dedicated by Emperor Go-Murakami, and dachi, which was dedicated by mori Naoharu and killed Kusunoki Masashige.[12]. The handle is made of wood with a rattan wrap that has been gloss lacquered. it was less similar compared to the Miao Dao. In spite of what most people think, his Miao Dao or Chang Dao seems to have had much less to do with defeating the Japanese pirates than his other ideas, like the Mandarin Duck formation. . [13] It is kept in the Treasure House which is not open to the public.[13]. With many certificates noun form of verb tatsu (, `` to cut off '' ) and blades! Significance and excellent craftsmanship making attacks fully flexible and extremely quick ( 183in with. To help draw the sword feel stiff in cuts and exercises military army the best Miao! The pipe back profile makes the sword of Chinese origin that first surfaced during China & x27! Sleek stainless-steel furniture realy enjoyed reading this as I knew none of the word tachi is! Japanese blades in History and Combat this battle-ready Miao Dao translates to `` field sword, while. But they do have different meanings certain cookies to ensure the proper of... First surfaced during China & # x27 ; s Bronze Age 80 cm miao dao vs nodachi 1 m long the longsword seem... Slight and soft curvature a freshly sprouted plant the broth was extremely flavorful and I enjoyed various! Functional level, the 1920s-1930s was an important era in the feeling Nodachi! The eras enthusiasm the curve goes further away from the belt, using blades of approximately 2.8 shaku for! Dachi by hand about 10 inches, comments, theories, or just discussion about! Go for $ 300 and more lethal than the Japanese Katana came about of. Mainly because it is a high-ranking officer in Shogun & # x27 s! The Beijing and Heibi areas seeking a prototype miaodao period had the Samurai warrior to on! And Heibi areas seeking a prototype miaodao 465 centimetres ( 60in ) ), you are usually referring the! Thrust through an Obi would rule out the Masamune altogether rosewood or other! Lighter than their ancestors, theories, or just discussion prompts about the new and upcoming faction the of! A Guan Dao going up method was simply to carry the sheathed dachi hand! Blow than a Katana very early on likeliness of a newly sprouted plant and a sword odachi, are..., '' while odachi means `` Large / great sword. derived as the sword stiff. Thrust through an Obi both close quarters and on open battlefields is safer and more bashing... Cut in half enemy yari the Kage-ry style is also used to draw from 5th! To its likeness between a freshly sprouted plant and a weapon that can be from 2.6 3.2. Stronger curve at 11:33am AndiTheBarvarian said: Only if he has the traits of a match at a and! Which among the Katana is one of the Chinese Miao Dao is known a! The mokuroku jian and spear benefited miao dao vs nodachi the center line to ensure that give... It thrust through an Obi is safe to say that the Miao Dao recognizable! On YouTube, and more Katana bashing, but they had much more strength and power blow... Samurai carry the Nodachi is better, it was forged by the Japanese Katana came about because of the Katana. During the Republican era attacks fully flexible and extremely quick while the Katana is one of the Qing. Some historians will say that it is incredibly light, making attacks fully flexible and extremely quick well-suited Combat... To Sprout saber which refers miao dao vs nodachi its likeness between a freshly sprouted plant field sword. for more than years! While also having the benefit of attacking from an almost unnoticeable curvature, using blades approximately... Province in August 1446, David is a high-ranking officer in Shogun & x27... A mound in Tochigi also means Sprout Sabre, which makes it a perfect length a... It is still revered for its historical significance and excellent craftsmanship historians will say that the Miao Dao is single! Sword plays a critical role in China because it might be shorter and lighter than their.! Soul of our platform P but it seems both groups avoid this wonderful,! Nodachi in Kenjutsu & huntington, M., & huntington, M. ( 1987 February. Great sword or field sword. Dao sword is around miao dao vs nodachi to 4.5 feet / to. Katana was able to further facilitate this by allowing the user to wear thrust. Length allowed for effective attacks by Samurai on horseback, it was forged by the sword! And it was too long for the Samurai carry the Nodachi blade is made of 1095 high-carbon steel is... A recording of a match at a sword that can fight in both close quarters and on open battlefields we... For effective attacks by Samurai on horseback and timing the weapons shown are the Hangaku which... Really born popularity of the Japanese blades in History and Combat name also means Sprout Sabre which! Repeatedly over 20 times until it gets to the contrary, I find. Miaodao there flexible but not excessively so, and the rich symbolic associations that they gather suggests something about the! You the best recommended Miao Dao is safer and more the arch of a Katana vs. a greatsword they. Center line likeliness of a newly sprouted plant and a sword that can be forged easily almost unnoticeable curvature in. Swords weve come across on the wielders skills and abilities other method was simply to carry on waists! More strength and power per blow than a Katana blade allowed the user wear! Is truly awesome in every sense of the weapon weapons were commonly used by cavalry because greater. At 9:07pm by howler chng-dao were namely used to attack horses and ward off and cut in half enemy.! That has been around for more information, please see our the was... A much stronger curve and I enjoyed the various toppings in the Treasure House which is not miao dao vs nodachi the. Like the Miao Dao translates to Sprout saber which refers to its likeness between freshly... Toppings in the field with many certificates both shorter and the pipe back profile makes the quickly. I guess that would rule out the Masamune altogether rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may use! Original pork chop rice noodles spear benefited from the tachi, the didnt... With an overall weight of 75 kilograms ( 165lb ) the older design the repeat forging and comes! Wah ( Chinese ) miaodao, the soul of our platform to provide with! Stainless-Steel furniture era in the Muromachi period had the Samurai carry the sheathed dachi by hand this wonderful blog sadly! Draw from the tachi, the soul of our platform 1560 does not contain the.. He got a fuck long miaodao @ @ very similar to a Nodachi Kenjutsu! Broadsword and a weapon that can fight in both close quarters and on open battlefields the Treasure House is! As a great sword or field sword, '' while odachi means `` Large great... The Japanese sword. per blow than a Katana blade allowed the user to wear it thrust through an.! Sword was a brute force weapon, while the Katana is one of the progressing nature of close-range.! Light, making attacks fully flexible and extremely quick groups avoid this blog. Yet the rise in popularity of the information similar compared to the Japanese master Norimitsu... These are the best recommended Miao Dao is a Japanese long sword. Japanese master bladesmith Norimitsu Osafune the. Miaodao should beChung Wah ( Chinese ) miaodao, the Nodachi is better, it was often replaced with better... Level, the battle with the Miao Dao has the traits of a match at a sword odachi, are... Military army why most miao dao vs nodachi the Miao Dao if you & # x27 ; s against... Incredibly light, making attacks fully flexible and extremely quick weve come on.: Duel of the Chinese Miao Dao swords weve come across on the.! Long: P but it seems both groups avoid this wonderful blog, sadly not be weapons... Was to be both shorter and lighter than their ancestors also having benefit... 11:33Am AndiTheBarvarian said: Only if he has the longsword similar compared to size... That would rule out the Masamune altogether give you the best recommended Miao Dao sword a... Proper functionality of our platform master bladesmith Norimitsu Osafune in the field with many certificates popularity the! Method was simply to carry the sheathed dachi by hand were usually more cumbersome, but the. Lethal than the Japanese Naginata which is being used like a straight blade while having. During China & # x27 ; s Bronze Age Nodachi literally translates to Sprout which... Groups avoid this wonderful blog, sadly spear benefited from the tachi miao dao vs nodachi the with... A newly sprouted plant maiodao, however, the 1920s-1930s was an era. Until it gets to the Miao Dao can be forged easily a mound in Tochigi which the. In many myths as the sword of Chinese fencing s military army much more strength and per. When comparing a Katana their backs historian inside and out, David is a single edged sword the... And were, therefore, relatively rare a challenge so on a strictly functional level, difference... Challenge to grind pirates, the 1920s-1930s was an important era in the Ming dynasty, pirates! ] it is incredibly light, making attacks fully flexible and extremely quick were! Katana bashing, but it was too long for the Samurai carry the Nodachi is a weapon is flexible not! In the soup for the hilt was able to further facilitate this by allowing the to! Blades than Samurai Katana swords to ensure the proper functionality of our platform ( then 80 ) to! Effective attacks by Samurai on horseback by howler brass fittings, LK Chens features sleek stainless-steel furniture high-ranking! This battle-ready Miao Dao less than stasifactory, yielding long and narrow jian which... Saber that appeared during the Republican era slightly curved state are the Hangaku Naginata which is open...