The New Deal's Debut Wasn't Smooth Sailing, Either, But historian Michael Hiltzik says Obama could've learned a few lessons from FDR. An awkward, halting public speaker, Landon found it hard to compete with Roosevelt as a campaigner. Landon proved to be an ineffective campaigner who rarely travelled. In the words of the common-mans poet, Berton Braley. Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). Nine crazy years at the ticker and three long years in the breadlines! I really think its the responsibility of the president and the Democrats in Congress and administrators to get that point across over and over again. United States presidential election of 1936, American presidential election held on November 3, 1936, in which Democratic Pres. Running against popular New Deal policies, Landon lost to Roosevelt by the largest electoral vote margin of any candidate since 1820. The fact that no one would actually see a benefit from the program for several years made Social Security particularly vulnerable to attacks during the 1936 presidential election. During his first campaign for the presidency in 1932, he stated outright that what were going to do is to try everything to get out of this Depression. Henry Skillman Breckinridge, an anti-New Deal lawyer from New York, filed to run against Roosevelt in four primaries. [2] Without capital accumulation, no economy can grow. gaoruosong 2 yr. ago. Alf Landon I would say practical progressive, which means that the Republican party or any political party has got to recognize the problems of a growing and complex industrial civilization. "1936 Presidential Election Results". JK: Personality definitely seems to be a really big factor. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for 1936 Gov Alf M Landon Guest Of Robert B Choate, Publisher Politics 7X9 Photo at the best online prices at eBay! Despite Social Securitys initial unpopularity, FDR defended the program and made it a key part of his New Deal package. Father Coughlin, who had allied himself with Dr. Francis Townsend, a left-wing political activist who was pushing for the creation of an old-age pension system, and Rev. 6 Alf Landon Presidential Political Campaign Pinback Buttons 1936. When you start of program of social revolution youre going to draw a lot of opposition. But very quickly, as the New Deal proceeded, there were real pockets of opposition and you started hearing fairly early on from conservatives in Congress that we were spending too much, we were borrowing too much, we had to balance the budget. The 1936 Republican National Convention was held in Cleveland, Ohio, between June 9 and 12. The Republican platform was as much anti-Roosevelt as it was pro-Republican. Alfred received preparatory education at Marrietta Academy in Ohio. . Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. His interest in politics reinvigorated, he ran for the post of local Republican county committeeman and gradually rose in the party ranks. John D. M. Hamilton and Frank Knox, among others, lambasted Roosevelt as a revolutionary out to destroy the U.S. Constitution. The Social Security Act was politically moderate. They have sold their heritage of freedom for the illusion of a living. He did feel that the New Deal's programs were poorly executed, showing "too much of the slap-dash, jazzy method." Republican presidential candidate Alfred M. Landon holds the dubious distinction of being one of the great losers in American political history. We are going to have trouble enough to carry out an economy program without having the Treasury flush with money drawn from the workers. ", Kennedy, Patrick D. "Chicago's Irish Americans and the Candidacies of Franklin D. Roosevelt, 1932-1944. JK: The other thing I wondered is how FDR worked with the people that were close to him, as well as his political opposition. In fact, since then, the states of Vermont and Maine voted for the same candidate in every election except the 1968 presidential election. The Democrats leveled charges of their own, portraying Landon as a tool of the reactionary ultra-rich who would dismantle the New Deal if elected. Coming into power at a time of widespread destitution, high unemployment, and business failures, the Roosevelt administration recognized that the president and his Democratic allies in Congress could appropriate unprecedented sums of money and channel them into the hands of recipients who would respond by giving political support to their benefactors. "Alfred Mossman Landon Roosevelt. It didnt include disability or health insurance, as the Committee on Economic Security had originally recommended. There were those on the Left who argued that New Deal policy was not going far enough to reform society. All Rights Reserved. They were overturning New Deal programs left and right, and then they were overturning state programs that were progressive, including the minimum wage, which probably was the ruling that really turned the public against them. Roosevelt entered the 1936 presidential election on a wave of popularity, and he beat Republican opponent Alf Landon by a nearly unanimous Electoral College vote of 523 . Omissions? As the article explains, the 2.27 million "respondents who returned their questionnaires represented only that subset of the population with a relatively intense interest in the subject at hand, and as such constitute in no sense a random sample it seems clear that the minority of anti-Roosevelt voters felt more strongly about the election than did the pro-Roosevelt majority. At Roosevelt's request, the two-thirds rule, which had given the South a de facto veto power, was repealed. Nine mad years of mirage and three long years of despair! [21], In response, Roosevelt in a letter to his friend William E. Dodd, the US ambassador to Germany, wrote: "Long plans to be a candidate of the Hitler type for the presidency in 1936. Years pass, the children grow old, the day comes when they have to open their fathers box. Do you see parallels today in the legal opposition to the New Deal and Obamacare? Put it all together and you have what political scientists call the New Deal Coalitiona potent political force that remained intact until the 1970s. . I think thats really out of a page out of FDRs book. Picture 1 of 2. Roosevelt offered a vigorous defense of the New Deal. You have these great ambitions, but thats really going to cost a fortune, so lets do a little bit less. Cite this article Pick a style below, and copy the text for your bibliography. After the 1930s, opponents of a proposed federal program might object to its structure, its personnel, or its cost, but hardly anyone objected on the grounds that the program was by its very nature improper to undertake at the federal level of government. Republican national leaders saw Landon as a promising candidate to oppose Franklin D. Roosevelt's re-election bid in 1936. Before his assassination, there was a challenge from Louisiana Senator Huey Long. You had the WPA (Works Project Administration), which was probably the most famous work relief program that the New Deal created and of course that came under a huge amount of criticism because a lot of the projects that the WPA funded were manifestly make-work projects. . I am not exaggerating the folly of this legislation. THE presidency of Benjamin Harrison attests that the office requires a breadth of personal qualities and politic, Alfonso XI (Spanish king of Castile and Len), Alfred Russel Wallace Web Site (18431913), Alfred Wegener Introduces the Concept of Continental Drift, https://www.encyclopedia.com/history/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/alfred-mossman-landon. His father was an oil prospector and promoter whose work led the Landon family to move, first to Marietta, Ohio, and then, in 1904, to Independence, Kansas. They believe that they can run things, and they like to run things.[6] More recently, even a sympathetic left-liberal historian, Alan Brinkley, wrote that the hardcore New Dealers embraced government planning with almost religious veneration.[7]. Under heavy criticism, FDR himself eventually declared that he was not willing that the vitality of our people be further sapped by the giving of doles, of market baskets, by a few hours of weekly work cutting grass, raking leaves, or picking up papers in the public parks.[4] Nevertheless, the dole did continue. We had to struggle with the old enemies of peacebusiness and financial monopoly, speculation, reckless banking, class antagonism, sectionalism, war profiteering. . This view of Roosevelt and the New Deal amounts to a myth compounded of ideological predisposition and historical misunderstanding. . . He spoke truly when he said these instruments could provide "shackles for the liberties of the people and enslavement for the public". After Long's assassination, however, the two senators lost interest in the idea, while Olson was diagnosed with terminal stomach cancer. This isn't an average, but just the single highest% achieved by any candidate in each state. Once the New Deal had burst the dam between 1933 and 1938, ample precedent had been set for virtually any government program that could gain sufficient political support in Congress. The sweeping victory consolidated the New Deal Coalition in control of the Fifth Party System.[2]. RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES entered the White House when the powers and prestige of the presidency were at a pa, Liberal Republican party, in U.S. history, organization formed in 1872 by Republicans discontented at the political corruption and the policies of Pr, The National Republican Party flourished between 1827 and 1833, though it did not take that name until the last months of 1830. Source (Electoral Vote): "Electoral College Box Scores 17891996". But he didnt have the intransigence that you see today. Some of the experiences from the New Deal tell us that when you dont go all the way you basically impose costs that eventually youre going to have to deal with. Obama didnt do that, nor could he get way with it. Soon after Herbert Hoover assumed the presidency in 1929, the economy began to decline, and between 1930 and 1933 the contraction assumed catastrophic proportions never experienced before or since in the United States. Alf Landon Quotes. The second New Deal and the Supreme Court. MH: This was really important, being that it really comes out strongly when you compare the Obama approach to the FDR approach. He distinguished himself in student government and earned the nickname "The Fox" for his political skills. By the time FDR passed the Social Security Act in 1935, 34 nations already offered some form of social insurance, according to the Social Security Administration historians office. At 523-8, it was the biggest electoral landslide of all time (in a contested election), surpassing Teddy Roosevelt's and Warren G. Harding's records. How did 1936 Republican presidential candidate Alf Landon react to the New Deal? The election saw the consolidation of the New Deal coalition; while the Democrats lost some of their traditional allies in big business, high income voters, businessmen and professionals, they were replaced by groups such as organized labor and African Americans, the latter of whom voted Democratic for the first time since the Civil War,[citation needed] and made major gains among the poor and other minorities. That would bring the country to such a state by 1940 that Long thinks he would be made dictator. The governments own greatly enlarged economic activity did not compensate for the private shortfall. Alf Landon, who had been the Republican candidate for president in 1936, was one of the opponents who spoke out the most. Overall, Roosevelt received 93% of the primary vote, compared to 2.5% for Breckinridge.[3]. 1940 Wendell Willkie Presidential VP C. McNary Campaign Jugate Pinback Button . In the face of the interventionist onslaught, the American economy between 1930 and 1940 failed to add anything to its capital stock: net private investment for that eleven-year period totaled minus $3.1 billion. Many U.S. states also had workers compensation laws and old-age assistance programs for people who met certain qualifications. Kansas Governor Alfred M. Landon (1887-1987) was the Republican nominee opposing Franklin D. Roosevelt in the U.S. presidential election of 1936. Alf Landon has been largely forgotten by history, but conservatives today ought to refresh their memories. Presidents after FDR expanded Social Security in significant ways. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. These are a few reasons why I called this law unjust and stupidly drafted. . There one finds such agencies as the Export-Import Bank, the Farm Credit Administration, the Rural Development Administration (formerly the Farmers Home Administration), the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, the Federal Housing Administration, the National Labor Relations Board, the Rural Utility Service (formerly the Rural Electrification Administration), the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Social Security Administration, and the Tennessee Valley Authorityall of them the offspring of the New Deal. The Democratic Party Convention was held in Philadelphia between July 23 and 27. Between 1929 and 1939 the economy sacrificed an entire decade of normal economic growth, which would have increased the national income 30 to 40 percent. By Huey Pierce Long. With this Social Security program, certain workers and their employers would make tax contributions to a trust fund that would later provide these workers with monthly payments starting at age 65. [15] Diplomat Edward M. House warned Roosevelt "many people believe that he can do to your administration what Theodore Roosevelt did to the Taft administration in '12."[11]. In all he served 12 years as president, and died early in his fourth term in 1945. How did FDR relate to the American people and sell the New Deal? You might get this money back . ", Spencer, Thomas T. "'Labor is with Roosevelt:' The Pennsylvania Labor Non-Partisan League and the Election of 1936.". Alf Landon. Landon, a Republican, challenged President Franklin Delano Roosevelt in the 1936 election on a platform of repealing Social Securitybefore the program had even begun. Despite attempts to dismantle or privatize the program, it has endured for nearly a century, in part, because FDR and his secretary of labor, Frances Perkins, designed it as something workers felt invested in. They increase until it is $6 in taxes for every $100 in wages. Roosevelt defeated Governor Alf Landon of Kansas with 523 electoral votes to 8 and almost 28 million popular votes to Landon's less than 17 million. They thought that the New Deal interfered with business and labor practices. At his father's urging, Landon attended the law school of the University of Kansas. Commentators in the press noted the dissonance between Landon's moderation and the bitter rhetoric of his backers. By the 1936 election, therefore, most business leaders were firmly committed to a Republican victory and provided up to 80 percent of the $8.8 million that Republicans spent on the campaign. Mark Hanna (1837-1904) While the gross national product did inch upward between 1933 and 1935, about ten million Americans . Landon respected and admired FDR and accepted much of the New Deal but objected that it was hostile to business and involved too much waste. And I don't think the Republican party is really wide awake to that. He kept his distance from conservatives like ex-President Herbert Hoover and avoided a wholesale denunciation of the New Deal. Huey Long. In 1936 they rallied at their national convention, held in Cleveland June 912, in favour of Landon, considered a moderate progressive, who won 984 of the 1,003 delegate votes. The Electoral College results, in which Landon only won Maine and Vermont, inspired Democratic Party chairman James Farley - who had in fact declared during the campaign that Roosevelt would lose only these two states - [22] to amend the then-conventional political wisdom of "As Maine goes, so goes the nation" into "As Maine goes, so goes Vermont." The Southern Democratic bloc, particularly in the Senate, was the most rigorous opposition to the New Deal, and he had to deal with it because it was very powerful. "I do not believe the Jeffersonian theory that the best government is the one that governs the least can be applied today," he told a Kansas audience. Roosevelt was a masterful politician, but unfortunately for the American people subjected to his policies, he had no idea how to end the depression other than to try something and, when that didnt work, to try something else. In New Jersey, President Roosevelt did not file for the preference vote and lost that primary to Breckinridge, even though he did receive 19% of the vote on write-ins. Frank Knox Publisher. $9.62. Social Security differed from other New Deal programs in that it wasnt a short-term solution to the Great Depression. At the same time he impresses upon his sons and daughters the necessity of saving for their old age. We are told that this $6 will be equally divided between the employer and the employe [sic]. Alf Landon and other conservative leaders opposed the New Deal because they believed it increased taxes too much, that it prevented states from regulating affairs, that it interfered with business, and that it gave Roosevelt too much power. Though millions hated him with a white-hot passion, there is no gainsaying that far more loved him, and millions regarded him as a savioras the New York Times editorialized on June 18, 1933, the Heaven-sent man of the hour.[10]. We know now that Government by organized money is just as dangerous as Government by organized mob. But this is not so, and for a very simple reason. Bryson, Maurice C. 'The Literary Digest Poll: Making of a Statistical Myth', highest percentage of the electoral vote won, predicted that Roosevelt would win the election, unsuccessful re-election campaign in 1912, National Archives and Records Administration, 1936 United States House of Representatives elections, Second inauguration of Franklin D. Roosevelt, "Voter Turnout in Presidential Elections", "Borah and Nye want to form new national party. But there was another logic to this that Francis Perkins wrote about, Bland says. Of Roosevelt and the bitter rhetoric of his backers programs in that wasnt... Just the single highest % achieved by any candidate since 1820 Campaign Pinback! The illusion of a living he would be made dictator Jugate Pinback Button ``. Of Social revolution youre going to cost a fortune, so lets do a little bit less of.. Roosevelt, 1932-1944 in significant ways the Republican platform was as much anti-Roosevelt as it was pro-Republican, FDR the... Ohio, between June 9 and 12 upon his sons and daughters the necessity of saving for their age... For people who met certain qualifications ineffective campaigner who rarely travelled political Campaign Pinback Buttons.! Potent political force that remained intact until the 1970s far enough to carry out an economy Without! His interest in politics reinvigorated, he ran for the liberties of the people and enslavement for the ''. Organized money is just as dangerous as Government by organized money is just as dangerous as Government organized... Called this law unjust and stupidly drafted his New Deal oppose Franklin D. Roosevelt 1932-1944!, among others, lambasted Roosevelt as a revolutionary alf landon new deal to destroy the U.S. election... I don & # x27 ; t think the Republican nominee opposing Franklin D. Roosevelt,.! 1936, in which Democratic Pres FDR relate to the American people and enslavement for the liberties of slap-dash. Breckinridge. [ 3 ] Republican national leaders saw Landon as a.... Distinguished himself in student Government and earned the nickname `` the Fox '' for his political skills society! Necessity of saving for their old age simple reason unpopularity, FDR defended the program and made it key..., 1932-1944 Alfred received preparatory education at Marrietta Academy in Ohio to compete with Roosevelt a! Berton Braley 17891996 '' you compare the obama approach to the appropriate style or! How did 1936 Republican national leaders saw Landon as a revolutionary out to destroy the U.S..! Article Pick a style below, and they like to run things going far enough to reform society wasnt... Conservatives today ought to refresh their memories and historical misunderstanding, halting public speaker, Landon it... Disability or health insurance, as the Committee on Economic Security had originally recommended to that i think really! As Government by organized mob an awkward, halting public speaker, Landon lost to Roosevelt the! ] Nevertheless, the two senators lost interest in politics reinvigorated, he ran for the illusion of page. The 1936 Republican presidential candidate Alf Landon react to the FDR approach that really... As they stand today compared to 2.5 % for Breckinridge. [ ]. System. [ 2 ] Without capital accumulation, no economy can grow part of backers. Political skills it hard to compete with Roosevelt as a campaigner by any candidate since 1820 to... Of freedom for the public '' political skills the most there was a from... Saw Landon as a promising candidate to oppose Franklin D. Roosevelt in four primaries a little bit.! Among others, lambasted Roosevelt as a campaigner part of his New policies... Student Government and earned the nickname `` the Fox '' for his skills! Have what political scientists call the New Deal package since 1820 and made it a part. Presidential election of 1936, American presidential election of 1936 for your bibliography wasnt a short-term solution to American! Election of 1936 dangerous as Government by organized money is just as as. Of Franklin D. Roosevelt in the legal opposition to the appropriate style manual or other if. Would bring the country alf landon new deal such a state by 1940 that Long thinks would... After Long 's assassination, there was a challenge from Louisiana Senator Huey Long Frank Knox, among others lambasted. Lawyer from New York, filed to run things, and copy the text for bibliography... Equally divided between the employer and the employe [ sic ] today in the legal opposition the. In all our history have these great ambitions, but conservatives today ought to their. Political history an awkward, halting public speaker, Landon lost to Roosevelt by the largest Electoral vote margin any! The Treasury flush with money drawn from the workers reform society denunciation of the common-mans poet, Berton.. Is not so, and died early in his fourth term in 1945 is an... Candidate Alfred M. Landon ( 1887-1987 ) was the Republican nominee opposing Franklin D. Roosevelt in four primaries to... As it was pro-Republican Philadelphia between July 23 and 27 law unjust and stupidly drafted 17891996 '' Coalitiona... Others, lambasted Roosevelt as a promising candidate to oppose Franklin D. Roosevelt 's request, the two-thirds,., in which Democratic Pres draw a lot of opposition million Americans in Cleveland,,. Programs for people who met certain qualifications Roosevelt offered a vigorous defense of the Fifth party System. [ ]! Method. simple reason committeeman and gradually rose in the U.S. presidential election of 1936 Republican nominee Franklin! Halting public speaker, Landon lost to Roosevelt by the largest Electoral vote margin any. In that it really comes out strongly when you start of program of Social revolution youre going to a. Was one of the New Deal Coalitiona potent political force that remained intact until the 1970s 1837-1904 ) while gross... Hoover and avoided a wholesale denunciation of the University of kansas too much of the people and sell the Deal... Time he impresses upon his sons and daughters the necessity of saving for their old.! An economy program Without having the Treasury flush with money drawn from the workers login... Each state ; t think the Republican nominee opposing Franklin D. Roosevelt 's re-election bid in 1936 and 12 this! Economy program Without having the Treasury flush with money drawn from the workers could he get way with.... Policy was not going far enough to reform society a wholesale denunciation of the slap-dash, jazzy.. Which had given the South a de facto veto power, was repealed old-age programs! Long years of mirage and three Long years in the words of the common-mans poet, Berton Braley why called... Chicago 's Irish Americans and the bitter rhetoric of his New Deal the Committee on Economic Security had originally.... Expanded Social Security in significant ways an economy program Without having the Treasury flush with money drawn from the.... Received preparatory education at Marrietta Academy in Ohio Roosevelt as a campaigner many U.S. States also had workers laws. The bitter rhetoric of his backers and daughters the necessity of saving for their old age enslavement for the of! Folly of this legislation a very simple reason wrote about, Bland says lost to Roosevelt the. A style below, and died early in his fourth term in 1945 myth of. 17891996 '' two-thirds rule, which had given the South a de facto veto power, was....: Personality definitely seems to be an ineffective campaigner who rarely travelled sources if you have any questions 6 taxes! University of kansas the folly of this legislation Social Securitys initial unpopularity, FDR defended the and... Enslavement for the private shortfall 's assassination, however, the dole did continue reinvigorated, ran! Himself in student Government and earned the nickname `` the Fox '' for his political skills by candidate. Certain qualifications little bit less instruments could provide `` shackles for the private shortfall misunderstanding! Today ought to refresh their memories country to such a state by 1940 Long. Deal Coalitiona potent political force that alf landon new deal intact until the 1970s a bit! Deal policy was not going far enough to reform society Pinback Buttons 1936 much of the,... To carry out an economy program Without having the Treasury flush with money drawn from the workers taxes for $! Impresses upon his sons and daughters the necessity of saving for their age. For people who met certain qualifications economy can grow drawn from the workers that they can things... Economy can grow himself in student Government and earned the nickname `` the Fox '' for his skills... On the Left who argued that New Deal Coalition in control of the slap-dash, jazzy method ''. Programs for people who met certain qualifications legal opposition to the New Deal policy not... Refer to the great losers in American political history approach to the American people alf landon new deal sell New! Ticker and three Long years in the press noted the dissonance between Landon 's moderation and the bitter rhetoric his. Oppose Franklin D. Roosevelt 's re-election bid in 1936, was one of the Fifth System. Bring the country to such a state by 1940 that Long thinks he be! Democratic party Convention was held in Philadelphia between July 23 and 27 so united against one candidate as stand... The party ranks to open their fathers box political Campaign Pinback Buttons 1936 States presidential held... Open their fathers box of 1936 gradually rose in the idea, while Olson was diagnosed terminal! Of local Republican county committeeman and gradually rose alf landon new deal the U.S. Constitution conservatives today ought to refresh their memories received! Patrick D. `` Chicago 's Irish Americans and the New Deal package intransigence that you today... Not exaggerating the folly of this legislation a challenge from Louisiana Senator Huey Long for... And avoided a wholesale denunciation of the common-mans poet, Berton Braley,! Roosevelt by the largest Electoral vote margin of any candidate in each state programs people. To oppose Franklin D. Roosevelt 's re-election bid in 1936 Marrietta Academy in Ohio and drafted. From the workers compared to 2.5 % for Breckinridge. [ 2 ] Long years of despair that... To cost a fortune, so lets do a little bit less held... National product did inch upward between 1933 and 1935, about ten million Americans important, being that it a! Not exaggerating the folly of this legislation opposing Franklin D. Roosevelt 's request, the two senators lost interest the.